# Abandoned cart calls: when a phone call beats email

Source: https://dialmilo.com/hub/abandoned-cart-calls
Updated: 2026-11-18

Abandoned cart calls recover orders email can't, but only for the right carts. Which ones to call, the consent rules, a full script, and the cost maths.

Abandoned cart calls are worth making for perhaps the top tenth of your carts by value, and for checkouts that stalled on a question a person can answer in thirty seconds: delivery, sizing, returns, a declined card. For everything else your email and SMS flow is cheaper and good enough. Call within a few hours, only people who agreed to be called, say it is an AI, ask what got in the way, and send the link by email afterwards. At roughly 14¢ a connected minute on a US number, a two-minute call costs well under a dollar, so the real constraint is consent, not cost.

Most guides on abandoned cart calls are written by people selling the calls, and they make the same move: quote a huge recovery rate from a single store, multiply it across your carts, and stop there. The honest version is less exciting and more useful. A phone call is the most persuasive channel you have and also the most intrusive. Use it where the cart is valuable and the shopper had a real question. Leave it out where they were window shopping.

## Why so many carts are abandoned, and which ones a call can fix

[Baymard Institute](https://baymard.com/lists/cart-abandonment-rate) puts the average documented abandonment rate at 70.22%, across 50 studies. That number alone tells you almost nothing about what to do, because the reasons matter more than the rate. In Baymard's survey of US shoppers, 42% said they abandoned because they were "just browsing" or not ready to buy. Among the rest, the reasons split like this:

| Reason shoppers gave (Baymard) | Share | Can a phone call fix it? |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Extra costs too high (shipping, tax, fees) | 40% | Sometimes. A call can explain free-shipping thresholds or a cheaper option, but it can't make the cost disappear. |
| Delivery too slow | 20% | Often. "Will it arrive by Saturday?" is the classic question nobody answers on a product page. |
| Didn't trust the site with card details | 19% | Partly. A calm call from the shop itself helps; it also must never ask for card details. |
| Site wanted an account | 18% | Yes, if guest checkout exists and the shopper didn't spot it. |
| Checkout too long or complicated | 17% | Rarely. Fix the checkout instead. |
| Website errors or crashes | 17% | Yes. "Sorry, that was us, here's a fresh link by email" saves the order and tells you about the bug. |
| Returns policy not good enough | 13% | Often. Policies read worse than they sound when explained. |
| Card declined | 10% | Yes, gently. Point them to another payment method by email. |

Read the right-hand column as your targeting rule. A call earns its place when the shopper had a question or hit a problem. It wastes everyone's time when they were comparing prices in six tabs. You can't know which is which before the call, but you can stack the odds: call carts above a value threshold, with a phone number the shopper gave on purpose, that are still open after your first email.

## Email first, phone second

Your email flow is the baseline, and it is a strong one. [Klaviyo's 2026 benchmark](https://www.klaviyo.com/blog/abandoned-cart-benchmarks), drawn from more than 110,000 of its customers, puts the average revenue per recipient for abandoned cart flows at $6.77 for email and $4.48 for text messages. An email costs a fraction of a cent. A phone call costs cents to dollars and a moment of the shopper's attention.

So a call should never replace the email. It should sit behind it, for the carts where the extra persuasion is worth paying for. A sequence that respects that looks like this:

1. **Within the first hour:** your normal abandoned cart email (and SMS, if you have consent for it).
2. **Two to four hours later, cart still open, value above your threshold:** an AI call.
3. **After the call:** the checkout link by email, or a note in the shopper's record so the next email reflects what they said.
4. **No second call.** If they didn't answer, one retry at a different time of day at most. Then back to email.

The threshold is yours to set, and it should come from margin, not order value. If your gross margin is 40% and a recovered order earns you $34 on an $85 basket, a call that recovers one order in ten conversations is clearly worth it. On a $25 basket earning $10, it rarely is.

## Consent comes before everything

This is the part to get right first, because getting it wrong costs far more than any recovered cart.

**United States.** In its [February 2024 declaratory ruling](https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-24-17A1.pdf), the FCC confirmed that the TCPA's restrictions on "artificial or prerecorded voice" calls cover AI technologies that generate human voices. Callers must obtain the prior express consent of the person called, and where the call introduces an advertisement or contains telemarketing, the FCC's rules require prior express written consent. A call nudging someone to complete a purchase is hard to describe as anything other than telemarketing. The same ruling points to the rule that every artificial-voice message must state clearly, at the beginning, who is responsible for the call.

**United Kingdom.** The [ICO's telephone marketing guidance](https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/direct-marketing-and-privacy-and-electronic-communications/guide-to-pecr/electronic-and-telephone-marketing/telephone-marketing/) separates live calls from automated ones. For automated calls, "general consent for marketing, or even consent for live calls, is not enough": the person must have specifically consented to that type of call from you. The guidance doesn't yet say in so many words whether a conversational AI agent counts as an automated call, so the cautious reading is to treat it as one.

What that means in practice: a phone number typed into a checkout form is a delivery contact, not permission for a sales call. If you want to call abandoned carts, add an unticked checkbox at checkout that says exactly that, for example "Call me if something goes wrong with my order or I leave items in my basket. Calls may be made by an AI assistant." Store when it was ticked. Only send carts with that flag to the calling step.

This isn't legal advice. It summarises the US and UK positions as of November 2026. Rules differ by country and by US state, and they change. Check with a lawyer before calling, and read our wider guide to [the laws on AI phone calls](/hub/ai-phone-call-laws).

## What good abandoned cart calls sound like

The best calls feel like customer service, not sales. The shopper hears who is calling, that it is an AI, and a reason that makes sense. Then the AI asks one question and listens.

> **Milo:** Hi, is that Priya? This is Milo, an AI assistant calling from Hollow Oak Bikes. You were looking at the Ridgeline gravel bike on our site earlier and didn't finish checking out. I wanted to see if anything got in the way.
>
> **Shopper:** Oh, right. Yes, I wasn't sure about the frame size. I'm five foot six.
>
> **Milo:** Our size guide puts five foot six between the small and the medium, and it depends on your inside leg. If you can measure that, the small fits up to 78 centimetres. Exchanges on an unridden bike are free within 30 days, so you can swap if it's wrong.
>
> **Shopper:** That helps. I'll measure tonight.
>
> **Milo:** Great. I'll make sure the link to your basket is in your inbox so you can pick up where you left off. Anything else I can help with?
>
> **Shopper:** No, that's it, thanks.
>
> **Milo:** Thanks, Priya. Enjoy the ride.

Notice what isn't there. No discount. No pressure. No card details. No reading out a link over the phone. The size answer and the exchange policy came from the shop's own information; the AI didn't invent a fit chart. And the promise at the end is something the shop's email flow actually does.

Hollow Oak Bikes is a made-up shop for this example; the structure is the point. Write your script as instructions, not a word-for-word speech, and give Milo the facts it needs: delivery times by region, the returns policy, the size guide, guest checkout. [AI call script templates](/hub/ai-call-script-templates) has examples you can adapt.

### On discounts

Resist the reflex. If every abandoned cart gets a 10% code by phone, shoppers learn that abandoning a cart is how you get 10% off. Keep any offer for a second-stage email to carts that stayed open after the call, and if you do mention one on a call, give the AI the exact terms in writing so it says them as written and doesn't improvise.

## Setting it up with Dial Milo

Dial Milo runs abandoned cart calls as a **manual campaign**: a script, calling rules, and a list that fills itself through a webhook. Every campaign has its own secret "start a call" URL. Anything that can send an HTTP POST can add a person to it.

  
    Create a manual campaign and write the script with placeholders for the details you'll pass in, such as `{recipient_name}` and `{cart_items}`. Any field you send in the webhook's `context` becomes a placeholder. Set calling hours (the default is 10:00 to 20:00 in each person's own local time), one or two attempts, a short longest-call limit such as three minutes, and a daily budget cap.
  
  
    In the campaign's settings, create its start-a-call URL. Treat it like a password: anyone holding it can queue calls on your account.
  
  
    In Shopify, a Shopify Flow workflow can do this. The [Customer abandons checkout trigger](https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/shopify-flow/reference/triggers/customer-abandons-checkout) starts the workflow; add a wait and conditions (cart value, your call-consent flag), then a [Send HTTP request action](https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/shopify-flow/reference/actions/send-http-request) that POSTs to the campaign URL. Shopify lists that action on its Plus, Advanced and Grow plans, and lets you keep the URL in Flow's secrets. Other platforms, Klaviyo flows or an in-house system can make the same POST.
  
  
    Send the checkout's own ID as `external_id`. Dial Milo ignores a person who is already waiting in that campaign's queue and any repeat of the same `external_id`, so a workflow that fires twice doesn't call twice. People on your do-not-call list are rejected automatically.
  
  
    Use **Test call** on the campaign page to hear exactly what a shopper will hear. Then abandon a real checkout on your own store and confirm the call arrives at the time you expect.
  

A payload might look like this:

```json
{
  "phone": "+14155550123",
  "name": "Priya",
  "external_id": "checkout-38122",
  "context": {
    "cart_items": "Ridgeline gravel bike, size not chosen",
    "cart_total": "1,240 dollars"
  }
}
```

After each call you get a recording, a transcript and a summary in the dashboard. Read the first fifty yourself. The summaries tell you which questions keep coming up, and those questions are the cheapest conversion fixes you will ever find: a delivery date on the product page, a clearer size guide, a guest checkout button people can see.

Two settings matter more than they look. **Contact limit across campaigns** stops anyone being called again within the number of days you choose, by any of your campaigns, so a shopper who abandons twice in a week hears from you once. And **calls at the same time** keeps your support line from flooding if shoppers ring back with questions. If they do ring the campaign number back, Milo recognises the callback and continues the conversation rather than greeting them as a stranger.

## What it costs, with the arithmetic

Dial Milo is pay as you go. On an outbound call you pay for the phone line, priced for the exact number dialled and your caller ID country and billed per started minute, plus 9.57¢ per minute of AI talk time. A US landline or mobile line starts at 4¢ a minute, so a connected minute is roughly 14¢. Calls that don't connect have no minute charge. You can price any number on the [rates page](/rates).

**Worked example, illustrative figures.** Say 400 carts a month clear your value threshold and have call consent. With one retry, that's about 600 dial attempts.

| | Calls | Cost each | Total |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Answered, about a 2-minute conversation (3 billed minutes) | 120 | about 42¢ | $50.40 |
| Reached voicemail, hung up without a message | 150 | up to about 14¢ | up to $21.00 |
| Not answered | 330 | no minute charge | $0 |
| **Total** | 600 | | **about $71** |

If one in seven of those 120 conversations ends in an order that would otherwise have been lost, that's 17 orders. At an $85 average basket and 40% margin, about $578 of margin for $71 of calls. If only one in twenty converts, it's 6 orders and about $204, which still pays. Your answer rate, talk time and conversion will differ, so plug your own figures into the [spend calculator](/help/using-the-spend-calculator) before you start, and set a budget cap so the maths can't surprise you.

To know whether calls really recovered those orders, hold out a random tenth of eligible carts that get the email but no call. Compare completion rates between the two groups after a fortnight. Without a hold-out, you'll credit the phone with orders the email would have won anyway.

## Mistakes that make these calls backfire

- **Calling every cart.** The browsers are the majority, and they are the people most annoyed by a call.
- **Calling too late.** After a day or two, most shoppers have bought elsewhere or moved on. Call while the decision is still open.
- **Not saying it's an AI.** Dial Milo discloses it at the start by default. Leave it on; finding out halfway through feels like a trick.
- **Asking for payment on the call.** Never take card details by phone in an automated call. Send them back to your checkout.
- **Leaving your pitch on voicemail.** Milo detects answering machines. Set the campaign to hang up on voicemail rather than leave your brand and the shopper's basket on a recording someone else might hear. Read more on [voicemail detection](/hub/voicemail-detection).
- **No stop button.** Anyone who asks not to be called again goes on your do-not-call list, and the webhook rejects them from then on.

## Where to start this week

Pick your threshold, add the consent checkbox, and run a small test: a few hundred carts, one campaign, a hold-out group, a budget cap. Read the transcripts. If the calls are recovering orders and the shoppers sound glad to hear from you, widen it. If they sound irritated, raise the threshold or stop. The wider playbook for campaigns like this is in our guide to [AI outbound calling](/hub/ai-outbound-calling), and if shoppers also phone you with order questions, an [ecommerce answering service](/hub/ecommerce-answering-service) handles that side. When you're ready, [create an account](/signup), hear Milo call you in the browser, and top up from $10.

## Frequently asked

**Do abandoned cart calls actually work?**

They work for a narrow slice of carts: high-value orders, and checkouts abandoned because of a question the shopper couldn't get answered, such as delivery dates, sizing, returns or a declined card. They do not work for the large share of shoppers who were only browsing. Published recovery figures for phone calls come mostly from vendors selling the calls, so test on your own carts with a hold-out group before trusting any number.

**How soon after abandonment should I call?**

Within the first few hours, inside sensible calling hours in the shopper's own time zone. A call the next morning still works for considered purchases like furniture or bikes. A call two days later mostly reaches someone who has already bought elsewhere or forgotten. Let your email flow go first and call only if the cart is still open.

**Is it legal to call someone who abandoned their cart?**

It depends on consent and the country. In the US, the FCC ruled in February 2024 that AI-generated voices are artificial voices under the TCPA, so you need the shopper's prior express consent, and written consent where the call is telemarketing, which a call encouraging a purchase usually is. In the UK, automated marketing calls need specific consent under PECR. A phone number typed into a checkout form is not consent on its own. Take legal advice for your situation.

**What should an abandoned cart call say?**

Say who is calling, that it is an AI, and why: they left something in their basket and you wanted to check whether anything got in the way. Then ask, and listen. Answer the actual question, offer to send the checkout link by email, and end the call. Leave discounts for later, if at all, because a reflex discount teaches shoppers to abandon carts on purpose.

**How much does an AI abandoned cart call cost?**

On Dial Milo you pay for the phone line, priced for the exact number dialled, plus 9.57 cents per minute of AI talk time, so a connected minute to a US number costs roughly 14 cents. A two-minute conversation costs well under a dollar and calls that don't connect have no minute charge. That is why the maths only works on carts worth more than a few dollars of margin.
